Showing posts with label anti-school movement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anti-school movement. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 11, 2026

The Book "Make it Stick" Shows that School is Against Neuroscience

This post is going to be about a must-read for adult autodidacts called "Make it Stick: The Science of Successful Learning" by Peter C. Brown, Henry L. Roediger III, and Mark A. McDaniel. This book is about how most learners are actually going about studying the wrong way. Furthermore, the public education system seems to be designed around vibes and myths about learning techniques that are unsupported by neuroscience. The authors of this book call these myths "education folklore." This book also provides techniques that you can use to actually learn instead of falling into illusions of competency.

the cover of the book "make it stick"

Learning is supposed to be hard 

One of the most important points in this book is that learning is supposed to be hard. If you don't make mistakes, you're not learning. Many learners fall into the trap of repeating easy tasks they are comfortable with. But "no pain no gain" applies to brain gains, don't forget! The authors are actually in favour of quizzes and tests, even though "education folklore" by woke snowflakes says that tests only lead to rote memorization and increased anxiety. However, the solution is actually to have several predictable low-sakes tests. Not pop quizzes, because those are universally hated. But not huge midterms or finals either as those are indeed anxiety-inducing and lead to cramming. Frequent, low-stakes quizzing is the way to go as this leads to effortful recall and makes things stick in your brain better. Without memory, there can actually be no progressing to more creative uses of knowledge. This means that while studying, you shouldn't be just re-reading passages but actually asking yourself questions and quizzing yourself. 

Also, stop being scared of mistakes and failure. They are necessary for growth. Take your ego out of it. 

Personally, I use Anki for memorizing vocabulary in Anishinaabemowin and I recommend it for all language learners out there (or even medical students, since y'all gotta memorize insane amounts of stuff). It follows the principles of this book because it doesn't show you flashcards you already know. It's going to be over a year before Anki shows me "miigwech," (the Anishinaabemowin word for "thank you," which I will never forget because it is literally seared into my brain, the first word I learned in the language and one that is familiar to many non-Indigenous people in southern Ontario). But it will show me "mshkiigimin" like every day, which means "low bush cranberry" and which I find way harder to recall. 

IQ isn't fixed 

Some of the most beautiful passages in this book are basically like poetry about human potential that show that IQ isn't fixed. Children who are taught that IQ isn't fixed don't back away from a challenge. They welcome the chance to stretch their brains. In a study, children who were called "smart," picked easier puzzles. Children who were called "hardworking" picked harder puzzles to solve! Have as scroll through some of these based excerpts. I took pictures of them while reading because they were just too good.

make it stick excerpt

make it stick excerpt

make it stick excerpt


"Learning styles" are like astrology, basically 

So I'm a former "gifted kid." This means that they put me in special classes because I had autistic special interests and liked books and I passed some kind of "gifted test" (it was lowkey kinda dumb, idk). One of the things that the teachers made us do every year for some reason in gifted classes from grades 4-8 was the "multiple intelligences test" by Howard Gardner. However, even Gardner himself admitted the concept of multiple intelligences is an art not a science. So we were forced to do this thing every year and take the results extremely seriously even though it has no scientific basis. School is against neuroscience. Unsurprising to many people, I scored very high in "verbal and linguistic intelligence" and pretty low in other categories. I was not logical/mathematical, visual/spatial, interpersonal, musical, or bodily/kinesthetic. I was a clumsy person who couldn't do math, couldn't draw, couldn't socialize and couldn't play music. I just read books. The multiple intelligences test asked me about stuff like my hobbies, so of course I picked options related to how I liked writing stories in my spare time. What that test really shows is simply what a child is interested in. That's it. It's basically just a hobbies quiz. It showed that I was very interested in reading and writing and not really in any other subject, which was true at that age. As I got older, I became interested in art, music, fitness, friendships, and even in math. But books have just been a first love (and true love) for me throughout my life. The test just showed what was obvious to everyone: I was just passionate about something. It didn't show anything about my intelligence. 

Also, stuff like "visual learner" or "auditory learner" is actually unsupported by neuroscience. Those also indicate preferences or interests, not what the most effective way you actually learn it. Learning styles or multiple intelligences are basically astrology. The teachers might as well have given us a Buzzfeed quiz about what icecream flavour you are and it would've been equally scientific. Make it Stick made me understand how cringe that was, and honestly it doesn't encourage a growth mindset because then you refuse to learn things that don't match up with your preferences. 

I actually think it did a lot of damage to me that the school system led me to believe that I wasn't a logical or mathematical person. I think I'd always have loved fiction or poetry more than math, but God I really could've used some encouragement for powering through with the math. It would've been better for me. I'm 25 now and I go to the library to read shit like "Statistics Essentials for Dummies" to figure out basic math now. 

If Wisdom is a goddess, school is desecrating Her altar 

Wisdom is personified as woman in the Bible, and many ancient cultures had goddesses of wisdom. But Wisdom lowkey woulda hated school. It is going against what she stands for. Become an adult autodidact, regardless of how shitty your school experience was. Do mathematical proofs on napkins at a restaurant. Read books while waiting in queues in public. Wisdom will come to you faster than it comes to your local director of the Board of Education. Books like Make it Stick can help you fix your brain after the damage that has been done to it by school. 

If you want to read more anti-school posts, check out this anti-school poem I wrote back in high school and this recent poem I wrote that personifies Wisdom. 

That's all for today. Good luck with learnmaxxing. 

Sunday, August 9, 2026

Anti-School Poem I wrote for Mnerva Literary Journal Volume VI: Wonder

Today I'm going to share a poem called "Grammar School" that I wrote and talk about my inspiration for it. I submitted this poem to Volume VI of Mnerva Literary Journal, which had the theme of "Wonder." The poem is about how school kills your sense of wonder. I had a great experience corresponding with Mnerva about this poem, and I highly recommend submitting to them if you write poetry. 

It's actually not the first time I've written an anti-school poem. You may remember this old post I wrote where I was digging through my high school poetry. This poem was about attaching your self-worth to grades, which are just numbers, and about how awful that feels. School can feel like no real learning is happening at all and that you are just trying to optimize for grades. 

However, this time I wanted to write a poem that was about how school also kills our natural sense of wonder and curiosity. I thought Mnerva was the perfect place to submit because of the "Wonder" theme. 

The Cover of "Wonder"

The cover of mnerva literary journal volume vi: Wonder has white blocky letters spelling wonder on a natural landscape background

I have to say, Mnerva did a great job of designing this cover. The font used to write "Wonder" is adorable and childlike. The font actually relates to the meaning of the word, which is great. It's a whimsical font. And the background looks like a mysterious forest ready to be explored. Also, the whole cover has a dreamlike quality. 

'Grammar School' -- A Poem

I am also a huge fan of the print layout. Very clean and well-designed. Here is what my poem, called 'grammar school,' looks like in print:

print layout of the poem 'grammar school' by Freya Abbas from Mnerva Literary journal on a glossy page with a serif font

The poem text:

Grammar School

he chews a pencil until his tongue is black
his teachers say it must have darkened
from uttering blasphemies
he holds back questions they don’t let him ask
some of them love the rod and strap
like he loves the snake in the garden
the one he says must have a soul
who can really blame them
for lording over schoolboys when
they have no say in their households?

he thinks about the ocean then
with all the secrets She holds
how could she possibly have been created?
surely there is more wisdom in pondering this
than in writing down words like
Temperance and
Prudence
and Reverence
when the school inspector comes for a visit

tonight someone has plucked the stars out of the sky
but he is too wise to think that darkness is emptiness
he does not understand why the others care for
the notion of light dispelling the dark
can they not see that the night is like a mother?
when he takes refuge in his chamber
she shelters him when his candle flutters out

Wisdom herself emerges out of the dark
where he was the only one who thought to seek her
she loves him the best and garlands him above
scowling schoolteachers with their eyes ablaze at children

The Inspiration 

My inspiration from this poem largely came from a class I took about Genesis, in which the professor told us about how people have been discouraged from questioning if there was anything that existed before God created the world, even though the beginning of Genesis actually makes it seem like water existed before God started his act of creation. That's why I included the line about the ocean. The boy in the poem gets punished for his curiosity because the teachers don't like it when he asks questions. I was also inspired by a desire to inverse Oxford University's Latin motto, which is "Dominus illuminatio mea" or "God is my light," and link wisdom with darkness instead of with light. Basically, I thought ignorance = darkness and wisdom = light is too cliche, and decided to switch the imagery. We do injustice to things we consider part of the darkness by refusing to study them.

Anyway, I hope y'all liked that poem and hearing about the inspiration behind it. It was really nice to see it in print. Don't forget to submit to Mnerva Literary Journal!!! You can submit to their regular issues, or try one of their contests that offer some prize money. Good luck!!!

What's next?


While we're on the anti-school theme, I'm reading a book right now called Make it Stick: The Science of Successful Learning that shows how school is against what neuroscience has actually proven about what helps people learn. I'll let you know my thoughts when I'm done. 

And what's next with my creative writing? I've been working on a poem from the point of view of Erasmus during his monastery days, another poem about a wolverine, a short about nuns in medieval Spain, and another short story about Babel from the Old Testament. Stay tuned to find out what becomes of these projects!!!